When Evangelicals Get To Heaven

0 Flares Filament.io 0 Flares ×

At the center of conservative Evangelical theology is the centerpiece of heaven and hell.

For them, nothing is more important. In their minds, hell is God’s eternal punishment for those who don’t respond in faith and faithfulness to the death and resurrection required of Jesus to save humanity from God’s wrath. With unending, unimaginable, and unbearable torture, fire, and pain, for Evangelicals, hell is the holy solution God creates for those who don’t respond properly to His unfailing love.

With this nearly singular focus on matters of eternity, conservative Evangelicals have been quick to first ensure their place in heaven, and then meticulously define those who will be sent to hell. Additionally, as they run their fingers through the Bible, they have been sure to carve out what they believe are the God-sanctioned requirements that must be met for one to truly have “saving” faith. From Calvinism to Arminianism, there are many different stances among conservative Evangelicals in regards to what “true” salvation involves. Yet, congruent in all of it is their focus on who’s in and who’s out. 

Inconvenienced and frustrated by what they see as a filthy, sinful, God-hating world, most conservative Evangelicals can’t wait to get into their heaven. For them, it’s a place absent of all their enemies, disagreers, problems, and cares filled only with people who believe, act, and look like themselves. Therefore, in the meanwhile of their earthly sufferings, the planet is theirs for their unlimited taking, prosperity and priority are entitled to the faithful, and people are projects to be converted into their believing that they might further create an earthly existence unto themselves of the like-minded and like-believing.

This is their heaven, devoid of diversity, disagreers, doubters, and the people who believe, act, and sin differently than they. It’s a walled-off place accessible only to the spiritually elite who have ascended to a certain set of beliefs and behaviors. Rewards and privileges are granted to the most faithful, and worship is joyfully extended to the god who sends, even from among their own, the unbelievers and rebellious to burn in hell. 

Yet, I wonder what their reactions might be if they aren’t rewarded with the heaven of their dreams. What would become of the expressions on their faces if eternity with God turns out to be an experience far removed from their expectations? What if, in heaven, the tables are turned on all the things they had hoped for and, instead, much the opposite is manifested and celebrated? What if the divine One isn’t as forever angry, cruel, and opposed to all the things they are?

Oh, the unconditional love of God in heaven that will forever feel, to them, like raging wrath as they are confronted with an eternity that is carpeted with an all-inclusive diversity of every size, shape, color, creed, sex, identity, spectrum, and orientation.

Oh, the torture that will forever plague their hearts as their eyes can’t escape a heaven where Jesus is robed in reams of rainbowed cloth, the sky snows glitter, and unicorns rule the fields.

Oh, the white hot coals that will forever heap fire upon their heads as they traverse a heaven that is ruled by pure Grace and overflowing with the presence of all their enemies happily reclined in the lap of Jesus.

Oh, the blood boiling rage that will forever consume their souls in a heaven where gay marriage, Transgender people, religious pluralism, women pastors, and racial equality dance in the streets while Jesus and George Michael spin the tracks.

Oh, the frustration that will send their bodies into uncontrollable tremors in a heaven where God is revealed to be genderless, colorless, flag-less, and gunless. 

Oh, the shame that will break their knees and press them into the fetal position in a heaven where the least of these are the greatest, the first are the last, the sinners are the saints, and the condemning, bigoted Christians are exposed of their folly. 

Oh, the fits of rage that will forever melt their skin from the inside out as the halls of heaven reveal the countless, earthly evils to which they subscribed and committed in the name of Jesus.

Oh, the embarrassment that will forever haunt their conscience in a heaven where God is Love, Grace is the Gospel, all are saved, the Bible is under, and Jesus is shown to have been over all and in all, all along—every person, every creed, and every place.

Oh, the dismembering dismay that will forever disarm their every faculty in a heaven where the clouds give constant witness that those outside the church were the most genuine in faith, the doubters were the strongest believers, the religiously oppressed were the favored, the nonbelievers were the included, and the questioning and resisting were the faithful.  

Oh, the psychotic mind-attacks that will forever terrorize their thoughts in a heaven where trumpets blast with crystal clarity as God parades the socialistic liberal, the desperate immigrant, the late-night McDonald’s worker, the foreign-born convenience store owner, the elderly Walmart greeter, the brave single mother, the caring stay-at-home father, the mentally ill, the disabled, the homeless, the uninspired, the undecided, the wandering, and the wayward as equal to all others, pure reflections of the Divine, and special recipients of the gleam in God’s eyes.     

Oh, what a terrible eternity that will be.

In fact, when Evangelicals get to heaven, for them, I’m thinking it’s going to be hell.


“Grace is the celebration of life, relentlessly hounding all the non-celebrants in the world.”   -Robert Capon

“The flames of heaven will be hotter for some than the flames of hell could ever be”  -Dallas Willard


Grace is brave. Be brave.


Check out Chris Kratzer’s new book getting rave reviews… Leatherbound Terrorism.

In Leatherbound Terrorism, Chris chases the evils of conservative Evangelicalism out of the shadows and gives powerful voice to the cries of the religiously oppressed. Confronting issues like racism, sexism, homophobia, religious greed, hypocrisy, nationalism, white supremacy, privilege, and the weaponizing of the Bible, Leatherbound Terrorism pulls no punches. Endorsed by best selling authors Steve McVey and Baxter Kruger, Leatherbound Terrorism will challenge you, inspire you, and most certainly cause you to rethink your faith and life.


  1. Catherine Quirion

    I am quite sure I am mangling this quote/story, but it goes something like this: C.S. Lewis and a friend are walking and discussing disturbing events. The friend says, “Not to worry, we’ll get what we deserve in the end.”

    Mr. Lewis replied, “I certainly hope we don’t.”

    • ckratzer

      Indeed! Thanks for reading and commenting Catherine.

      • Valerie Allen

        Just found your web site again. This is such a good read..thank you for saying what so many of us just think and would so like to say. I am totally convinced that you are logical and clear in stating that Jesus’ teachings are about inclusion and humility. The first shall be last etc could not be clearer. Thanks.

  2. Valerie Allen

    Just found your web site again. This is such a good read..thank you for saying what so many of us just think and would so like to say. I am totally convinced that you are logical and clear in stating that Jesus’ teachings are about inclusion and humility. The first shall be last etc could not be clearer. Thanks.

    • ckratzer

      Thanks so much for reading and commenting, Valarie!

  3. gary

    Hey Chris… I’m with ya on all the misconceptions and narrow-minded projections the Christians I grew up with tend to attach themselves to. But I suspect (I mean, who knows… nobody does, that’s why death and life remain a mystery) that, once on the other side, all misconceptions and attachments of any sort will dissolve in the unflinching Love that is God’s essence, and there will be no second guessing or gnashing of theological teeth, only insightful and nurturing Love. Notions of heaven and hell in such a sea of awareness, if recognized at all, will be found to be quaint shards of humanity’s futile neurotic attempts to understand and control the Mysterious. All evangelical earthly fixations aside, what I found my dying evangelical parents most fixated on was being re-united with loved ones on the other side.

  4. Gary Bryson

    Since kratzer believes everyone goes to Heaven, why is he objecting to what anyone does or believes?

  5. Todd Vick

    As always, you get right in the face of elite, exclusive, evangelical arrogance and call it out to face the hard truth about their version of Churchianity.

  6. Cheryel Lemley-McRoy

    I never heard a preacher preach on Matthew 25:31-46. I think that’s because Jesus says he will call all the nations of the world, and that is not only Christians, but includes Jews, Muslims, Hindus, Buddhists, pagans, atheists, and agnostics. Jesus implies that there will be some of each in each line. And I suppose that this is where some will cry, Lord, Lord.
    Perhaps no preacher ever preached this passage because Jesus’ criteria didn’t include a Sinner’s Prayer, Bible reading, church attendance, or tithing.
    But then again, all of us will be surprised at how wrong we were.

  7. Jay Hansen

    We all need to read more often Jesus’ parable of “The Ever-Forgiving, Ever-Gracious Father” more commonly called (or misnamed) “The Prodigal Son.”

    If we are honest with ourselves, we cheer for the ingrate, elder son who snaps at his father: “Listen [old man]!! For all these years I have been working like a slave for you, and I have never disobeyed your command; yet you have never given me even a young goat so that I might celebrate with my friends. But when this son of yours came back, who devoured your property with prostitutes, you killed the fatted calf for him!” The father then replies, “All that is mine is yours. But we had to celebrate and rejoice, because this brother of yours was dead and has come to life; he was lost and has been found.”

    We and the elder brother want to see retribution. We just aren’t satisfied and grateful enough for all we have received.

    Thank you too for quoting Robert Farrar Capon. I love his writing and so many of his choice quotes. If your readers don’t know him, they should read his books.

  8. Rob

    You come across like that which you rail against. I hope universal salvation is true, I detest the doctrine of eternal punishment, and have suffered from it most of my life, but it’s a shame you can’t seem to be able to convey your beliefs and criticisms of American Evangelicalism without the rancor and red-faced rage. Also, did you forget that the doctrine of eternal punishment is taught in churches led by and attended by people who aren’t white?

    Maybe try to not come across as the chaplain to Antifa.

    • ckratzer

      Rob, thanks for you comments. In my opinion, it seems like you are determined to miss the point of this article and deflect the truths of it through an attempt to tone-police my writing. Apparently, this article has confronted you in some way. I hope that confrontation brings forth increased wisdom for you. Thanks again for you comments.

  9. Tony Cutty

    This is great. CS Lewis said something similar in ‘Screwtape Proposes a Toast’, where Screwtape finds out that the wine at the banquet is vintage Pharisee. I won’t go into details, but you’ve hit it pretty square on. Well said 🙂

  10. Cameron Thomson

    Wow. Talk about an ecstatically cruel and vengeful screed this is. How are you not simply the mimetic double of your enemies/rivals, pastor Chris?

    Are there people out there that resemble the people you so clearly loathe? Sure. But then, too, there are people like me–and many others I know–who, because we’ve the wrong views on sex, human reproduction, and gender, specifically, would be blindly lumped together with this tiny minority. I read this and DO NOT RECOGNIZE MYSELF AT ALL in his description off what you call “evangelicals.” And yet: I feel profoundly hated.

    Elsewhere (http://chriskratzer.com/white-christian-privileged-ashamed/) you state: “I used to be a conservative, Evangelical, racist, homophobic, sexist, judgmental, and spiritually arrogant pastor and person. With no reservation, I pre-cataloged blacks as inferior and dangerous subhuman creatures, the LGBTQ community as mentally ill and spiritually depraved, and women as cupholders and casserole-makers for men.”

    Speak for yourself then. That DOES sound awful. But talk about PROJECTION.

    I’m reminded of Robin DiAngelo, to whom I say, again: speak for yourself. I believe it: YOU are a racist (i.e., a would-be anti-racist racist). And no doubt YOU feel fragile in the face of your inner conviction about this and the powerful imperative, which comes from the little that remains of Christianity in our culture, to leave off being a racist. Stop projecting your racism and fragility on others though.
    Just stop, Robin. Just stop, pastor Chris. Stop poisoning everyone else’s conversations.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

© 2024 Chris Kratzer

Theme by Anders NorenUp ↑

0 Flares Twitter 0 Facebook 0 LinkedIn 0 Email -- Filament.io 0 Flares ×
%d bloggers like this: